In short. A ketogenic diet cuts carbohydrates so much that the body makes ketones as fuel. It produces weight loss, especially at first. The most controlled studies show, however, that with equal calories it doesn’t burn more fat than other diets. Long term, results come close to those of standard diets.
This article opens the Diets put to the test series: every Thursday, one popular diet checked against research.
Does this sound like you?
- You lost weight fast on keto, then regained it.
- You’ve been told it’s the only way to “burn fat”.
- You miss bread and your social life suffers.
- You want to know if it suits you before starting.
What studies have observed
Equal calories (2016). Kevin Hall and colleagues at the US National Institutes of Health housed 17 men in a metabolic ward where every meal was weighed. After a month on a high-carbohydrate diet they switched to a ketogenic diet with the same calories. Energy expenditure rose slightly, and body fat loss slowed during the first weeks of keto. Published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
Eating freely (2021). The same group compared, in 20 adults, two weeks of a plant-based low-fat diet with two weeks of an animal-based ketogenic diet, with food freely available. On the low-fat diet people spontaneously ate 550-700 fewer calories a day. Both diets produced weight loss, but only the low-fat diet significantly reduced body fat. Keto gave lower, steadier blood sugar and insulin. Published in Nature Medicine.
Long term (2013). A Brazilian meta-analysis of 13 trials with over 1,400 participants compared keto with low-fat diets for at least a year. Keto produced on average just under 1 kg more weight loss. Published in the British Journal of Nutrition.
What it means for you
Keto works like other diets when it leads you to eat fewer calories. The first kilos lost are partly water linked to carbohydrate stores. It can make sense in specific, medically supervised situations, such as drug-resistant epilepsy or some obesity programmes. Many people find it hard to sustain, and weight tends to return when it stops.
What we don’t know yet
Metabolic-ward studies are short. Solid data on years of keto and heart health are lacking: in some people LDL cholesterol rises sharply, and we can’t yet predict who. The type of fat used, animal or plant, may also change results.
How I approach it
The Gasparri Method™ uses Six Sigma in an applied way: I choose the eating pattern based on the person’s data, tests and preferences, within an orthodox plan.
- An initial assessment of tests, medication and habits.
- A sustainable pattern, chosen with you.
- Keto only when indicated, for a defined period and with medical checks.
- An exit and maintenance plan, prepared from the start.
Interested in this topic? On Thursday 26 November the next article in the series comes out: Intermittent fasting put to the test: does it beat a standard diet? Follow me on social media or subscribe below to get it by email.
Get new articles by email
Every new blog article is emailed to subscribers on the day it is published. Emails are in Italian, with a link to the English version at the top of each article. Subscribing is free and you can unsubscribe at any time using the link in every email.
Frequently asked questions
Does keto burn more fat? In controlled studies with equal calories, no.
Is it dangerous? For healthy people, short term and supervised, it’s generally well tolerated. With treated diabetes, kidney disease, pregnancy or eating disorders it should be avoided or decided by a doctor.
If you take diabetes medication, especially insulin or SGLT2 inhibitors (gliflozins), don’t start a ketogenic diet without your doctor.
About the author
Dr. Giulia Gasparri, Ph.D., registered nutritionist (Biologa Nutrizionista), Italian National Order of Biologists (Section A, no. ToU_A3124), with a PhD in molecular biology and Six Sigma Green Belt certification. Since 2019 she has seen patients with Global Nutrition in Foligno, Italy, and online worldwide.
Sources
- Hall KD et al. Energy expenditure and body composition changes after an isocaloric ketogenic diet in overweight and obese men, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2016 — link
- Hall KD et al. Effect of a plant-based, low-fat diet versus an animal-based, ketogenic diet on ad libitum energy intake, Nature Medicine, 2021 — link
- Bueno NB et al. Very-low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet v. low-fat diet for long-term weight loss: a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials, British Journal of Nutrition, 2013 — link


Lascia un commento